
Muzaffarabad (Pakistan-occupied Kashmir), November 19 (H.S.): The Supreme Court of Azad Jammu and Kashmir (AJK) has set aside the decision to completely abolish regional and refugee quotas in government employment, ruling that geographical preferences are not inherently unconstitutional but must be backed by legal provisions and evidence of under-representation.
According to a report in Dawn, a division bench comprising Chief Justice Raja Saeed Akram and Justice Khalid Yousaf Chaudhary, in a judgment delivered on Wednesday, directed the Public Service Commission (PSC) to resume and complete all pending recruitment processes that had been suspended following the High Court's August 16, 2025, ruling.
However, the Supreme Court stopped short of restoring the decades-old quota percentages. Instead, it directed the government to undertake a comprehensive review of the existing regional and refugee allocations and bring them in line with constitutional and statutory requirements. The court also prescribed an interim geographical framework for recruitment.
Under this framework, vacancies in Grades 1 to 7 will be filled through competition among candidates from the respective constituencies, while posts in Grades 8 to 15 will be filled at the district level.
Vacancies in Grades 1 to 15 in divisional offices will be filled through competition among candidates from the respective divisions. Meanwhile, appointments to state-level institutions, irrespective of grade, as well as all posts in Grade 16 and above, will be made on open merit among State Subjects.
The Supreme Court clarified that selection within each geographical area would remain strictly subject to prescribed qualifications, suitability and merit. If no suitable candidate is available within the designated geographical area, the recruitment process may be extended to a wider area in accordance with the applicable rules.
In the judgment authored by Chief Justice Akram, the court observed that the High Court had erred in treating all regional, area-based or refugee-related recruitment arrangements as inherently unconstitutional. It noted that the legal framework established under the AJK Civil Servants Act, 1976, and the Civil Servants Rules, 1977, recognises the government's authority to ensure adequate representation for different regions of Azad Jammu and Kashmir and refugees settled in Pakistan.
However, the bench emphasised that this authority was not unlimited and that historical quota arrangements could not continue indefinitely without a rational and objectively verifiable justification.
The bench also examined separately the quotas reserved for refugees settled in Pakistan. It observed that their status as State Subjects was independent of whether any particular quota or preferential allocation remained in force.
The court held that neither the 19 per cent quota for refugees who migrated in 1947 nor the six per cent allocation for those who arrived in 1989 could be treated as a permanent entitlement without a continuing and sound constitutional and legal basis.
On admissions to educational institutions, the court ruled that regional preferences must be examined separately from recruitment to government jobs. The bench also set aside the High Court's directions concerning federal and provincial institutions and educational seats that fell outside the constitutional and administrative jurisdiction of the AJK government. It observed that such matters were governed by their respective constitutional, statutory and inter-governmental arrangements.
The Supreme Court further ruled that appointments and admissions already completed under the laws in force at the relevant time should not be disturbed solely on the basis of its judgment.
The court also held that the High Court lacked the jurisdiction to declare the quota arrangements contrary to the injunctions of Islam, as the authority to examine such questions rests with the Shariat Appellate Bench under the relevant law.
---------------
Hindusthan Samachar / Jun Sarkar