
Kolkata, 20 November (H.S.) : The Calcutta High Court on Friday expressed strong displeasure over Trinamool Congress MP Abhishek Banerjee's recent remarks against the judiciary. Despite its sharp rebuke, the court granted him relief by extending his interim protection until January 29.
During the hearing, Justice Saugata Bhattacharyya made it clear that such statements are not expected from a Member of Parliament, questioning what kind of message such remarks send to his followers. Describing the comments against the judiciary as extremely painful and unacceptable, the judge observed that while Banerjee's remarks may not amount to deliberate and calculated contempt of court, they could easily have been avoided.
Citing Banerjee's comments, the state government opposed the extension of his interim protection. In response, Justice Bhattacharyya asked the state whether a plea for extending interim protection could be rejected solely on the basis of remarks made against the judiciary, and whether the statements could be termed wilful contempt. The court also sought to know if any new or altered circumstances had emerged that would warrant withdrawing or refusing to extend his protection.
Clarifying the legal position, the judge stated that the two issues are entirely separate. He noted that if appropriate circumstances arise, contempt of court proceedings can be initiated, which constitutes a completely distinct legal process.
Meanwhile, appearing for Abhishek Banerjee, advocate Ayan Bhattacharyya submitted that the remarks pertain to a different matter. He informed the court that he had no knowledge of where or what statements his client had made regarding the court or the judiciary, and therefore could not comment without consulting him and obtaining necessary instructions. However, the counsel unequivocally stated that he does not support any remarks made against the court.
---------------
Hindusthan Samachar / Satya Prakash Singh