
Nagpur. 19 Nov
(HS): Surrogacy has been a hot topic of discussion in the recent the recent
past. Review of ancient literature and traditional practices are being studied.
The law enacted in 2021 and enforced in December 2025 speaks volumes about surrogacy,
but appears inadequate to address the issue at National and International
levels. The traditional practices have taken shape of commercial business and
women accept to become surrogate mothers for want of money are being exploited
for want of a fool proof law relation to the issue.
Surrogacy practices
date back of mythological period, relating to birth of Pandavas and Kauravas
and even Lord Ram and his brothers.
Indian mythology
has a strong connection with spirituality, social and moral ethics, which is
based on philosophical and cultural roots. Earlier genetic origin was given
importance, which was followed by commercial exploitation of women willing to
act as surrogate mothers.
Over the past
few years, legal changes changed carried out considering ethical, social practices
and constitutional provisions.
Mamta Kachore-Gomase
has carried out a detailed study on the aspect for her doctoral degree. She has
dealt with all the aspects- traditional and present legal aspects and has been
awarded PhD for her research by the Rashtrasant Tukadoji Maharaj Nagpur
University. The topic of her was ‘Legal aspects of Surrogacy in India – An Analytical
Study’. The research speaks volumes of practices in India and loopholes or deficiencies
in the existing laws relating to surrogacy.
The issue for
serious consideration came to the forefront following historical decision in
Baby Manji Yamada v/s Union of India case bringing to the spotlight the plight
of a Japanese infant through and India surrogate mother,
The issues
related to compensation to surrogate mother, her emotional attachment to the
child, inheritance, nationality etc were raised. Genetics origin was also
involved in the case. The legal lacunae for welfare of the surrogate mother and
the child came to the fore. The compensation paid was and is insufficient for
the surrogate mothers for leading a healthy life in the future. Many women
suffer from various health related issues during pregnancy. Only post-partem
(After birth of the child) insurance is limited to 36 months. The expenses during
the pregnancy is paid by the couple or person intended. The child’s rights were
also under consideration.
Mamta Kachore-Gomase
has considered all these aspects in her doctoral research and has based on her observation
made several suggestions.
Suggestions:
1, Need for a special
independent national authority to regulate surrogacy and assisted reproductive technologies,
create national registry, certify clinics and redressal mechanism.
2. Clarity and
enforceability of the law.
3. Legal
Literacy.
4. Exclusive
policy framework and informed consent.
5. Healthcare
norms and aftercare.
6. Monetary
compensation.
7. Judicial
training and sensitization.
8. Systematic
Centre-State coordination, e-data systems for effective cooperation.
The research in depth need further study for
framing laws and the regulating surrogacy in India.
India has been
hub of surrogacy in the past. The women, normally from economically weaker
sections, were exploited by the middlemen. India has been also popular in
entire world for the surrogacy, which has come down drastically after the enforcement
of law in 2025. Genetic consideration has been included while framing the law.
Now ovum and sperm of biological father is considered for surrogacy to prevent
genetic origin ailments or deficiencies. Besides these issues the issue of
inheritance was also considered.
However, the complicated
subject is of further research and frame law accordingly.
---------------
Hindusthan Samachar / Ajay Vasant Mardikar