
Wellington (New Zealand), November 19 (H.S.): India’s batting coach Sitanshu Kotak has defended the team management’s decision to leave fast bowler Mohammed Siraj out of the playing XI for the first Test against New Zealand. He emphasised that Siraj is a “world-class bowler”, but said the management believed the combination selected for the match was the best possible option under the prevailing conditions.
India fielded a four-pronged pace attack in the opening Test against New Zealand, comprising Jasprit Bumrah, Prasidh Krishna, Akash Deep and Anshul Kamboj, while Siraj was left out of the playing XI. The selection decision sparked considerable discussion among cricket fans.
According to Cricbuzz, speaking at a press conference after the first day’s play in Wellington, Kotak explained the rationale behind Siraj’s exclusion. He said there was nothing wrong with the fast bowler and that he saw no reason for concern. The team management felt that the selected combination was the best possible one and decided to take the field with that XI.
Referring to India’s previous tour of Sri Lanka, Kotak said the playing conditions there were different from those in New Zealand. Siraj had featured in both Test matches during the Sri Lanka tour.
However, Kotak reiterated that Siraj was a world-class bowler. He explained that India had opted for a bowling attack offering considerable variety. Two of the bowlers were particularly effective at generating seam movement, while the other two were adept at producing swing. He added that pace was also an important consideration.
Kotak said that on a pitch that was slightly damp and soft at the start, with a substantial covering of grass, having a tall bowler could prove advantageous as it helped generate additional bounce.
He further pointed out that this was only the first day of the Test and that the surface would develop marks and rough patches as the match progressed. Therefore, while selecting the playing XI, the team management had to consider the requirements of all four or five days rather than focusing solely on the opening day.
Siraj’s omission was not the only selection decision that attracted attention. India also preferred Washington Sundar over Ravindra Jadeja as the spin-bowling all-rounder. Explaining the reasoning behind this choice, Kotak said New Zealand had a relatively large number of left-handed batters in its line-up.
He said the presence of four left-handed batters influenced the decision to include an off-spinner. He added that the team had to consider not only the first innings but also the second innings while making its selection. Washington was also capable of making a valuable contribution with the bat.
Kotak acknowledged that Jadeja was an outstanding all-rounder who had delivered excellent performances for the team.
As for the match, New Zealand had reached 243 for five in their first innings by the close of play on the opening day of the first Test against India in Wellington. At stumps, Henry Nicholls remained unbeaten on 113 off 221 balls, including 14 boundaries, while Glenn Phillips was batting on 94 off 182 deliveries, having struck 13 fours.
For India, Jasprit Bumrah led the bowling effort with three wickets, while Anshul Kamboj and Akash Deep claimed one wicket apiece.
Hindusthan Samachar / Jun Sarkar